After the enormous success of the Up! project, Shania Twain released a top-selling Greatest Hits album in 2004, which spawned three singles. She then embarked on an extended hiatus before returning in 2011 with a new single and a reality series on The Oprah Winfrey Network. In this set of retro single reviews, we'll take a look at Twain's six most recent single releases to date.
“Party for Two” (with Billy Currington or Mark McGrath)
2004
Peak: #7
The first single from Twain's Greatest Hits package was her last Top 10 country hit to date, but only the second Top 10 hit for her then-up-and-coming duet partner Billy Currington. The premise is shamelessly silly, as are the spoken word intro and the “You'll be sexy in your socks” line, but Twain and Currington sell it with flair. Twain delivers her verses with a flirty, playful performance, while Currington renders his with the same laid-back smolder that would become his calling card at country radio.
In the tradition of the Up! album, “Party for Two” was released in both a country and pop mix, with Sugar Ray's Mark McGrath appearing as Twain's duet partner on the latter. Unfortunately, McGrath's performance lacks the character needed to sell a song of this ilk, and the gaudy pop arrangement has aged poorly in comparison to the country mix, demonstrating that Twain was often at her best when keeping a toe in country waters.
Written by Shania Twain and Robert John “Mutt” Lange
Grade (Currington version): B+
Listen: Party for Two (with Billy Currington)
Grade (McGrath version): B-
Listen: Party for Two (with Mark McMcGrath)
“Don't!”
2005
Peak: #24
The soft, dobro-driven arrangement is the perfect fit for this angst-filled ballad. Twain performs the song in an emotive almost-whisper of a delivery, while the evocative melody conveys regret and desperation with a tinge of hope.
Written by Shania Twain and Robert John “Mutt” Lange
Grade: A-
Listen: Don't!
“I Ain't No Quitter”
2005
Peak: #45
The third and final single from Twain's Greatest Hits fizzled due to lack of promotion. Quite possibly Twain's countriest single since “No One Needs to Know,” “I Ain't No Quitter” lacks the lyrical cleverness of Twain's best work, but she elevates the song through her fun, laid-back performance. Likewise, the bouncy, fiddle and steel drenched arrangement is a delight.
Written by Shania Twain and Robert John “Mutt” Lange
Grade: B
Listen: I Ain't No Quitter
“Shoes”
2005
Peak: #29
A rare instance in which Twain worked with a team of co-writers in addition to her then-husband, “Shoes” was written for inclusion on a Desperate Housewives companion album, but the boot-stomping fiddle-laden arrangement would have not have sounded out of place on The Woman In Me.
The lyric draws on a series of humorous double-entendres comparing men to footwear. (“Some make you feel ten feet tall, some make you feel so small, and some you want to leave out in the hall or make you feel like kickin' the wall”) The concept is pure novelty, but Twain pulls it off brilliantly with a catchy everywoman-sing-along chorus and an in-on-the-joke vocal performance.
Written by Shania Twain, Robert Johnn “Mutt” Lange, Tammy Hyler, Joie Scott, and Kim Tribble
Grade: B+
Listen: Shoes
“Today Is Your Day”
2011
Peak: #36
In the wake of Twain and Lange's divorce, “Today Is Your Day” was the first Twain single since the days of her debut album not to be produced by Lange. Unfortunately, David Foster's production lacks the freshness and restraint of Lange's work, with a clutter of instruments distracting from Twain's performance instead of spotlighting it.
Twain's vocal exudes sincerity, vulnerability, and age-earned wisdom, but struggles to overcome the fact that the lyrics amount to little more than a string of inspirational clichés. Add some unnecessary vocal processing on top of that, and Twain's comeback single falls greatly short of the event that it should have been.
Written by Shania Twain
Grade: C+
Listen: Today Is Your Day
“Endless Love” (with Lionel Richie)
2012
Peak: #12 (U.S. Adult Contemporary)
A remake of Richie's classic 1981 hit duet with Diana Ross, from his country duets project Tuskegee. It starts out on a pleasant note, but gradually devolves into an overwrought shouting match that seems to go on forever as Richie and Twain attempt to force emotion into the song.
Written by Lionel Richie
Grade: B-
Listen: Endless Love (with Lionel Richie)
Previous: It Only Hurts When I'm Breathing
I agree with you on “Party for Two”, particularly that the Currington version is a lot better than the McGrath version. I particularly like “I Ain’t No Quitter.” “Today’s Your Day” is terrible, especially because I thought it was a likeable song the way she did it on that reality show that she had. David Foster really cluttered it up.